
A cost model for the CFO who keeps hearing "we already have someone doing this"
Manual dental insurance verification costs a DSO in three ways: staff hours (verifications × minutes × loaded wage), rework and write-offs when benefit details are missing, and appointments seen unverified when the verifier is out. CAQH puts the transaction alone at $4.37 per portal check in 2023, and that figure leaves out gathering information and follow-up.
Ask a dental group what insurance verification costs and you'll usually get a payroll answer. A couple of coordinators at the busy offices, whoever has a free minute at the front desk everywhere else, and maybe an offshore team for the overflow. It looks like a cost you already know and already budget for.
That answer covers one of the three costs. The other two show up later and never hit the payroll line. One lands in write-offs, adjustments and awkward patient-balance calls. The other lands in the week the person who verifies for three of your locations is out.
Below, we break verification into those three cost lines and work through an example for a 25-location group. Where there's a published number we use it and link it. Where there isn't, we say so and label the assumption. You should come away with a number you can defend before you price any alternative, whether that's another hire, an outsourced team or software.
Dental practices and plans spent $2.1 billion on eligibility and benefit verification in 2023, up 15% in a year, according to CAQH's 2024 Index. ADA News reported it as the largest increase in dental administrative spending that year.
Even that figure is a floor. CAQH's per-transaction costs count the transaction itself, "not the time and cost associated with gathering information for the transaction and follow-up." Gathering and follow-up are most of what a verification team does all day. They log into the portal, read through the plan's frequencies and history, key it all into the PMS, and pick up the phone when something doesn't add up.
So the model starts with the labor you can see, then adds the two lines you can't.
This is the line you already partly know. Per location, the formula is:
verifications per month × minutes per verification × loaded hourly cost
Run it per location, then add up the group. Volume, payer mix and staffing are different at every site, and a group average is a good way to hide the locations that are struggling.
Verifications per month. Count every insured appointment on the schedule. Plans change between visits more often than people expect. An employer switches carriers, a frequency resets, a patient burns through their maximum, and last month's breakdown is already out of date. Pulling a full breakdown at every visit is how you catch that before it turns into an incorrect claim. Your PMS appointment data will give you the count. Across Foji's dental customers, volume averages about 35 verifications per location per day.
Minutes per verification. This is the input that moves the total most, and nobody has published a reliable dental figure for a full benefit breakdown. CAQH's 2024 Index doesn't break dental verification time out by method. The figure everyone quotes is older. CAQH's 2021 data, as reported by the Colorado Dental Association in 2022, put a manual verification at a minimum of 12 minutes, with follow-up roughly doubling it. You'll also see 15 to 30 minutes quoted to office managers, though we couldn't find a source for that range. Your own number is better than any of these. Time five verifications at three locations and use the median.
Loaded hourly cost. The Bureau of Labor Statistics puts the mean hourly wage for insurance claims and policy processing clerks working in dental offices at $21.02, and receptionists at $20.41 (BLS, May 2023). Then add benefits, payroll taxes and overhead with a loaded-cost multiplier. There's no standard dental figure for that, so you'll have to set your own. The example below assumes 1.3.
A sanity check from CAQH. CAQH estimates a dental provider's cost per eligibility and benefit verification at $6.52 manual (phone, fax), $4.37 partially electronic (portals, IVR) and $2.53 fully electronic, for 2023. Multiply your monthly volume by the portal figure and you have a lower bound. If your hours-based number comes in under it, your minutes are probably too low.
This is the expensive line, and most groups don't track it.
When a breakdown is missing a frequency limit, a waiting period or a prior service date, you usually find out after the patient has been seen. The claim denies or underpays. Someone calls the payer. Then the balance gets adjusted, or billed to a patient who was told something different at the front desk, and some of it ends up written off.
Electronic eligibility doesn't close this gap on its own. CAQH reports that dental providers often don't get enough detail from automated responses to trust them, and quotes one practice directly: "When it comes to eligibility and benefits, I don't have an automated tool that I can trust, so I don't use it." That's why full breakdowns still mean portal work. It's also why a team that's behind on the day's schedule is tempted to pull the minimum and move on.
The rework line has two parts.
Follow-up time. The closest published proxy is a claim status inquiry. CAQH puts a dental claim status inquiry by phone at 18 minutes, and the provider cost at $12.01 manual against $3.71 electronic. Estimate how many of your verifications each month end in a follow-up call because something in the benefits was wrong or missing. Price those calls at that rate.
Write-offs tied to benefit errors. There's no published dental benchmark for this, and we won't invent one. Outside dentistry, 50% of providers in Experian Health's 2025 State of Claims survey named missing or inaccurate data as a top reason for denials, up from 46% the year before. Treat that as healthcare-wide context. Your own number lives in your PMS adjustment data (Open Dental groups can start with our Open Dental RCM optimization guide). If your group doesn't tag adjustments by cause yet, it's worth starting now. Sixty days of tagged data will tell you more than any benchmark we could quote.
Every group has a version of this. The person who verifies for a cluster of locations takes a week off, or gets sick, or quits. Someone else picks up some of the queue, some of it gets done late, and some of it just doesn't get done before the patient's in the chair.
Nobody budgets for it because it doesn't happen on a schedule. You can still model it with three inputs:
The output is the number of appointments a year that each location sees without a verified breakdown. Multiply it by the write-off and rework rate from cost line 2 to put a dollar figure on it.
It also goes a long way toward explaining why verification quality varies so much from one location to the next. If one person is a location's whole coverage plan, that location is always one sick day away from a bad week.
Here's the model for a hypothetical 25-location group. We've marked the sourced figures. Everything else is an illustrative assumption, so swap in your own numbers.
Cost line 1, hours. 35 × 21 = 735 verifications per location per month. At 15 minutes each, that's about 184 hours. At $21.02 × 1.3 = $27.33 an hour, it comes to about $5,020 per location per month, or about $125,500 a month and about 4,590 hours across 25 locations.
CAQH cross-check: 735 verifications at the $4.37 portal cost is about $3,210 per location per month. The hours-based figure is higher, as it should be, because CAQH's number excludes gathering information and follow-up.
Cost line 2, rework. 5% of 735 is about 37 follow-ups per location per month. At $12.01 each, that's about $440 per location, or about $11,000 a month across the group, plus about 11 hours per location on the phone.
Write-offs come on top, and they depend on your data. As a sensitivity check, every $500 per location per month in benefit-related write-offs adds $12,500 a month across 25 locations.
Cost line 3, coverage. 35 appointments × 15 days × 50% = about 260 appointments a year per location seen without a verified breakdown, or about 6,560 across the group. Apply your own write-off rate from line 2 to price it.
What the total means. In this example, lines 1 and 2 alone come to about $5,460 per location per month, roughly $137,000 a month across the group, before any write-offs or coverage gaps. Look at the 4,590 hours a month again. That's time your team spends logging into portals, and it could be going to denials, AR follow-up and the exceptions that really need a person's judgment. We make the longer case for moving that time to higher-value work in Your Dental Office Doesn't Need More Staff. It Needs Less Work.
Run the hours line with your own numbers. The verification cost calculator on our DSO page takes your locations, monthly volume, minutes per verification and loaded hourly cost, and returns staff hours and cost per month and per year across the group.
Before you take any of this to a budget meeting, keep two limits in mind.
First, every industry figure here is an average across very different practices. CAQH's costs also leave out information gathering and follow-up by design, so treat them as floors and sanity checks.
Second, the three inputs that move the total most are the ones only you can measure: minutes per full breakdown, the share of write-offs tied to benefit errors, and what happens to the queue when someone's out. A few weeks of measuring your own team will beat any benchmark.
There are two ways to get those numbers. You can time and tag the work internally for 30 to 60 days. Or you can run a short pilot against your own patients and payers, which ends up measuring the same things along the way.
Once you have a baseline, price every option against it on the same terms: another hire, an outsourced verification team, or automation. Foji was built for the three lines above.
It's a flat monthly rate per location with no per-verification fees, so it sits next to the number you just built without any volume math. You don't need a new hire to run it.
The fastest way to replace this model's assumptions is a 2 to 4 week Foji pilot against your own workflow and payer mix. You get measured numbers for your locations before you make any staffing decision. Groups adding locations can see how this works at scale on our DSO page, or read why fast-growing DSOs are automating their revenue cycle.
CAQH's 2024 Index puts a dental provider's cost per eligibility and benefit verification at $6.52 manual, $4.37 partially electronic and $2.53 fully electronic, for 2023. Those figures leave out gathering information and follow-up, so a full breakdown done in staff time usually costs more. Time your own verifications to get the real number.
The most-cited figure is CAQH's 2021 data, reported by the Colorado Dental Association: a minimum of 12 minutes per manual verification, with follow-up roughly doubling it. There's no newer published dental figure for a full breakdown, so the median of a few timed verifications at your own locations is the best input.
Multiply verifications per month by minutes per verification. In the example above, 35 verifications a day (the average across Foji's dental customers) at 15 minutes each comes to about 184 hours per location per month. Your volume and minutes will differ by site.
There's no published dental benchmark. The number lives in your PMS adjustment data, so tag adjustments by cause for 60 days to measure it. Healthcare-wide, 50% of providers in Experian Health's 2025 survey named missing or inaccurate data as a top reason for denials.
Part of the queue gets covered, part gets done late and part doesn't get done before the visit. Model it as days out per year × appointments per day × share of the queue missed. In the example above, that's about 260 appointments a year per location seen without a verified breakdown.
Related reading
A 30-minute call: how your team verifies today, then recorded runs of the agent doing the work in Open Dental and Dentrix.
Book a demo